Oturan Online

The Official Forum of the naruto orpg, Oturan Online!

Welcome to Oturan Online
Hungry? Try checking out the Ramen Shop!
Please read the forum rules here!
Embrace the power of the Curse Mark! Check it out Here!
Log in

I forgot my password



Affiliates
Vbgore Vs Eclipse Mmorpg11
Free Domains Forwarding
 
Latest topics
» Hello everyone, again!
Vbgore Vs Eclipse EmptyTue Mar 03, 2015 10:17 pm by radori

» Heyo, its a blast from the past
Vbgore Vs Eclipse EmptyTue Mar 03, 2015 11:39 am by radori

» Christian Louboutin Flats
Vbgore Vs Eclipse EmptyTue Jan 22, 2013 3:07 am by cangliang

» Christian Louboutin Cheap
Vbgore Vs Eclipse EmptyTue Jan 22, 2013 3:06 am by cangliang

» Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes
Vbgore Vs Eclipse EmptyTue Jan 22, 2013 3:05 am by cangliang

» Prada Belt
Vbgore Vs Eclipse EmptyThu Jan 17, 2013 3:23 am by cangliang

» Armani Belts
Vbgore Vs Eclipse EmptyThu Jan 17, 2013 3:22 am by cangliang

» gucci belt for men
Vbgore Vs Eclipse EmptyThu Jan 17, 2013 3:21 am by cangliang


You are not connected. Please login or register

Vbgore Vs Eclipse

Which engine should be used for Oturan Online?

Vbgore Vs Eclipse Vote_lcap60%Vbgore Vs Eclipse Vote_rcap 60% [ 3 ]
Vbgore Vs Eclipse Vote_lcap40%Vbgore Vs Eclipse Vote_rcap 40% [ 2 ]
Total Votes : 5

Go down  Message [Page 1 of 1]

1Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Wed Sep 23, 2009 5:12 pm

Oturan

Oturan
Kage
Kage
Vbgore Vs Eclipse Vbvsec10

As you guys know Oturan Arena has been the focus of attention for a while, and it still will be for even longer. But even then, the original Oturan Online should be slowly working in the background. Oturan Arena will be keeping everyone busy, and having fun while i get hard at work on the coding of oturan, and the spriters spriting one a day. But now i need help making this important decision. To use Eclipse 3.0 or Vbgore.

~Pro's of Eclipse:
-Much more friendly community, for help on anything we need.
-Easy program to use.
-Not much programming needed to make it decent.
-Very quick to make a game.
-Team Building (team can work on the game, in game)
Thats basically it......


~Cons of Eclipse:
-Crappy graphics
-No shadows
-When games are released they only have 2-3 people on at a time....
-Very limited, unless programmed.
-Limited animations
-Engine isn't even released...
-Static GUI
-The new engine has been "coming soon" for almost a year now.
-Very snobby community that rejects fan games.
-No summoning
-& alot more...


Summary: Eclipse will get Oturan done quick but poorly.
Eclipse Website

~Pros of VBgore:
-Amazing Graphics!
-Live Shadows!
-Its already released
-Extremely Flexible game editing.
-Summon Type Jutsu
-2/3D, looks more on the 3D side.
-Makes maps detailed, with fog, rain, snow and more.
-Unlimited file sizes.
-Sprites can be any size we want.
-Particle Effects for jutsu. (doesn't require sprites for it)
-Walk, Run, and Attack Animations.
-Isometric movement, and run blur.
-MySQL server hosts instead of just hosting from my computer.
-Built in Updater
-Built in Action Bar (jutsu icons)
-Alot more i can't remember.


~Cons of Vbgore:
-Takes a while to learn Visual Basic (proramming language)
-Requires more time to add in parts of the game.
-Will take a little longer to develop, but its worth it IMO.


Summary: Much more Professional game, longer development time.
Vbgore Website

~Comparison~

*Oturan in Eclipse(recently)
Vbgore Vs Eclipse Testma11

*Oturan in Vbgore(few months ago)
Vbgore Vs Eclipse Oorebo11

So the question is:
Vbgore Vs Eclipse Vbvsec10



Last edited by Oturan on Sat Sep 26, 2009 8:56 pm; edited 1 time in total

http://oturanonline.ultimaterpg.org

2Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Wed Sep 23, 2009 6:52 pm

GuzmanM

GuzmanM
Spriter
Spriter
Actually, VBgore is ALOT better, but I have my private reasons for choosing Eclipse!

3Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Wed Sep 23, 2009 6:53 pm

Oturan

Oturan
Kage
Kage
Private? XD

Do you mind telling me, so i can make my decision eventually Smile

http://oturanonline.ultimaterpg.org

4Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Wed Sep 23, 2009 8:07 pm

radori

radori
Genin
Genin
Damn, VBgore is alot better than eclipse lol
maybe it would be worth the wait
Question

5Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Wed Sep 23, 2009 8:08 pm

Oturan

Oturan
Kage
Kage
lol. well you'll have Oturan Arena to run around in tongue

Plus, im sure if i just take 2-3 weeks of practice on it, ill get it down. Just pure trial and error. lol



Last edited by Oturan on Wed Sep 23, 2009 8:09 pm; edited 1 time in total

http://oturanonline.ultimaterpg.org

6Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Wed Sep 23, 2009 8:09 pm

radori

radori
Genin
Genin
Yea, i vote for VbGore
XD

7Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Wed Sep 23, 2009 8:19 pm

Oturan

Oturan
Kage
Kage
lol can you vote so i don't forget.

2 VB, 1 E3 Smile

http://oturanonline.ultimaterpg.org

8Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Wed Sep 23, 2009 9:05 pm

Ninjamouse1

Ninjamouse1
Veteran
Veteran
Looking at the list and visiting the site i have to say VB gore, that's my vote.

9Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Wed Sep 23, 2009 9:25 pm

Oturan

Oturan
Kage
Kage
lol, yea im really liking VBgore, just wanted the opinion on if you guys would prefer a better game and longer dev, over bad game/fast dev.

Vbgore is just amazing!
Look a mini map!
Vbgore Vs Eclipse V100_04

Shocked

The look of it, is just... i can't describe it! XD

Enjoy the screen shots:
Vbgore Vs Eclipse 07

Vbgore Vs Eclipse V100_02

Vbgore Vs Eclipse V100_03

Vbgore Vs Eclipse V100_15

http://oturanonline.ultimaterpg.org

10Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Wed Sep 23, 2009 10:24 pm

Ninjamouse1

Ninjamouse1
Veteran
Veteran
Yeah i saw all those pics of the site, i haven't tried downloading the engine though, somebody told me it was really complex and you had to get like 4 different programs lol.

11Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Thu Sep 24, 2009 6:41 am

Oturan

Oturan
Kage
Kage
4? lol

You actually only need one. The engine

Then if you want to host you need MySQL

And if you feel like programming, then Visual Basic.

Yeah, its complex unlesss you just use the default graphic.
Smile

http://oturanonline.ultimaterpg.org

12Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Thu Sep 24, 2009 11:41 am

GuzmanM

GuzmanM
Spriter
Spriter
Actually, it will be good to tell why I love more Eclipse than VBGore...but...shame on me...that's why I said PRIVATE reasons

13Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Thu Sep 24, 2009 4:02 pm

Oturan

Oturan
Kage
Kage
What, you can't program, so you use eclipse?

The poll isn't about what you can do, so dont make it private. Its about what you would like in the game.

http://oturanonline.ultimaterpg.org

14Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Thu Sep 24, 2009 6:19 pm

Ninjamouse1

Ninjamouse1
Veteran
Veteran
Oh, i guess the guy i was walking to must have been hosting so that's why he needed the extra program.

15Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Thu Sep 24, 2009 6:22 pm

Oturan

Oturan
Kage
Kage
yea. Ill be hosting too, so yea i will need the 3 programs which i already have tongue

Unless i get someone else to host. I don't think my computer will be able to handle hosting a HUGE mmo, and still be used normally.
Question

http://oturanonline.ultimaterpg.org

16Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Sat Sep 26, 2009 5:31 am

YoungCoco

YoungCoco
Veteran
Veteran
Can I just point out that you have only used one of your original test maps for the Eclpise thing. People who have actually worked on eclipse to create games have made a hell of a lot of better map tiles, and, it seems to be an easier to understand set up.

I have seen a game made on VbGore, and I have to admit, it wasn't as impressive as what you have there. Honestly, I would check the games that have been made with those engines before making any comparisons.

17Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Sat Sep 26, 2009 7:08 am

Oturan

Oturan
Kage
Kage
hm.... I see what you mean.
Question

But its kinda mainly on you. Being the graphics guy, do you want to work with restricted features. I mean 3.0 will have bigger sprite sheets. But the fact that we cant start until it comes out just kind of sucks to me. Second the more i look at the eclipse 3.0 development, the more i think it would be cool. I think its best to work on all graphics, and wait till eclipse 3.0 is released to make the decision.

Eclipser Dev Pages

http://oturanonline.ultimaterpg.org

18Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Sat Sep 26, 2009 9:11 pm

Oturan

Oturan
Kage
Kage
Ive seen some updates on Solar Eclipse in java. Looks pretty cool, so im gonna check out some java in the mean time.
Smile

Vbgore Vs Eclipse A7deb73c592960820717cecbd17c3d0b
Vbgore Vs Eclipse 8b95893eac4c58dcead35f6e3506b8ffVbgore Vs Eclipse 961b815546a10abbe6259f30263ca849

http://oturanonline.ultimaterpg.org

19Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Sat Sep 26, 2009 9:24 pm

Ninjamouse1

Ninjamouse1
Veteran
Veteran
Yeah Solar eclipse is looking really good, its nice and smooth i guess.

20Vbgore Vs Eclipse Empty Re: Vbgore Vs Eclipse on Sun Sep 27, 2009 12:21 am

Oturan

Oturan
Kage
Kage
yea. I hope they follow through and release it by the end of this year Smile

http://oturanonline.ultimaterpg.org

Sponsored content


Back to top  Message [Page 1 of 1]

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum